Hmm; it looks like it’s numbered right in MB. I’m not entirely sure what to suggest—if you’re feeling up for it, maybe consider diving into the beets.autotag.apply_metadata function and printing out a few values to see if you can see what’s going wrong for that track?
Or, it might just be a problem in the printouts from the importer. You could try applying the match and then seeing if it does the right thing (even though it doesn’t say that it will).